BarShelf: Home Bar AI vs Crouton: Recipe Manager
BarShelf: Home Bar AI
Define You
App Store
$5/mo
~$55/yr · 400 installs
VS
Crouton: Recipe Manager
Crouton LLC
App Store
$15.1K/mo
~$181.0K/yr · 218K installs
Revenue winner
Crouton: Recipe Manager wins
+301640% vs other
Installs winner
Crouton: Recipe Manager wins
+54340% vs other
MAU winner
Crouton: Recipe Manager wins
+60445% vs other
Rating winner
Crouton: Recipe Manager wins
+42% vs other
Why Crouton: Recipe Manager is winning
Top 4 reasons - backed by the public App Store / Play Store numbers.
- Crouton: Recipe Manager earns roughly 3017× more per month than BarShelf: Home Bar AI - $15.1K vs $5.
- Aggressive pricing. Crouton: Recipe Manager undercuts at $1.99/mo vs $3.99/mo - converts a higher % of free users.
- Bigger install base. Crouton: Recipe Manager has ~218K lifetime installs vs BarShelf: Home Bar AI's ~400 - 544.4× the funnel top.
- More monetization surfaces. Crouton: Recipe Manager runs 8 IAP tiers vs 3 - more chances to convert users at the right price.
→ Find more apps with this revenue gap · Full Crouton: Recipe Manager report
Side-by-side metrics
Bars scale to whichever app is bigger on that row. Green = winner.
BarShelf: Home Bar AI
vs
Crouton: Recipe Manager
Monthly revenue (est.)?
$5
▶
$15.1K
Annual revenue (est.)
$55
▶
$181.0K
Lifetime installs (est.)
400
▶
218K
Monthly active users (est.)?
42.8
▶
26K
App Store rating
3.40★
▶
4.82★
Total ratings
5
▶
3K
US grossing rank
-
=
-
Cheapest monthly sub
$3.99
◀
$1.99
IAP tiers detected
3 tiers
▶
8 tiers
- Category
- Food & Drink
- Price
- Free
- Released
- Oct 31, 2025
- Last updated
- Jun 23, 2026
- File size
- 76.5 MB
- Content rating
- 17+
- Version
- 4.3
- Languages
- English, French, German, Italian, Japanese, Korean +2 more
- Category
- Food & Drink
- Price
- Free
- Released
- Sep 2, 2019
- Last updated
- Apr 20, 2026
- File size
- 348.2 MB
- Content rating
- 4+
- Version
- 2026.1
- Languages
- English, French, German
BarShelf: Home Bar AI trajectory
Crouton: Recipe Manager trajectory
FAQ
Which makes more money, BarShelf: Home Bar AI or Crouton: Recipe Manager? v
Crouton: Recipe Manager earns about $15.1K per month, while BarShelf: Home Bar AI earns about $5. That is a 3017.4× revenue gap (~$15.1K more per month for Crouton: Recipe Manager). Annual revenue: BarShelf: Home Bar AI ≈ $55/year, Crouton: Recipe Manager ≈ $181.0K/year. Estimates are derived from public App Store signals - grossing rank, scraped IAP tiers, ratings and category benchmarks.
Which has more downloads, BarShelf: Home Bar AI or Crouton: Recipe Manager? v
Crouton: Recipe Manager leads with about 218K estimated downloads vs 400 for BarShelf: Home Bar AI - a 544.4× gap. BarShelf: Home Bar AI's App Store downloads are estimated from 5 ratings × the standard 1:75 ratio. Crouton: Recipe Manager's App Store downloads are estimated from 3K ratings.
Are BarShelf: Home Bar AI and Crouton: Recipe Manager in the same App Store category and competing for the same money? v
Yes - both apps sit in the Food & Drink category, which means they compete directly for the same paying users and category-level wallet share. Direct competitors, head-to-head.
What in-app purchases and subscription pricing do BarShelf: Home Bar AI and Crouton: Recipe Manager offer? v
BarShelf: Home Bar AI: IAP range 3 tiers detected. Crouton: Recipe Manager: IAP range 8 tiers detected. BarShelf: Home Bar AI runs a "Subscription (~$3.33/mo)" monetization model; Crouton: Recipe Manager runs "Subscription (~$17.99/mo)". Scraped tier prices and detected subscription pricing drive the bulk of the per-app revenue estimate above.
Which has better ratings, BarShelf: Home Bar AI or Crouton: Recipe Manager? v
Crouton: Recipe Manager edges ahead with ★ 4.8 vs ★ 3.4 (gap of 1.4 stars). Rating volume: BarShelf: Home Bar AI 5 ratings, Crouton: Recipe Manager 3K ratings. Higher rating volume = stronger ASO signal even when star averages are close.
How accurate are these BarShelf: Home Bar AI vs Crouton: Recipe Manager revenue estimates? v
Directional - typically within 2-3× of actual money earned for popular apps. The $5 for BarShelf: Home Bar AI and $15.1K for Crouton: Recipe Manager are derived from App Store grossing rank, scraped IAP tiers, ratings volume and category benchmarks (Food & Drink) - net of the 15-30% Apple/Google store cut. Real revenue depends on country mix, retention, refunds and ad fill rate, none of which Apple or Google publish.
How do I compare BarShelf: Home Bar AI or Crouton: Recipe Manager to a different App Store app? v
Use the search box at the bottom of this page or paste any two App Store links into the homepage tool. We auto-generate a permanent comparison URL with revenue, downloads, IAP tiers, subscription pricing and grossing rank for both apps.