Goat Simulator 3 vs Melon Sandbox
Goat Simulator 3
Coffee Stain Publishing
Google Play
$16.8K/mo
~$201.9K/yr · 108K installs
VS
Melon Sandbox
playducky.com
Google Play
$316.4K/mo
~$3.80M/yr · 104.8M installs
Revenue winner
Melon Sandbox wins
+1781% vs other
Installs winner
Melon Sandbox wins
+97031% vs other
MAU winner
Melon Sandbox wins
+18656% vs other
Rating winner
Melon Sandbox wins
+9% vs other
Why Melon Sandbox is winning
Top 4 reasons - backed by the public App Store / Play Store numbers.
- Melon Sandbox earns roughly 19× more per month than Goat Simulator 3 - $316.4K vs $16.8K.
- Subscription model. Melon Sandbox runs a $11.29/mo subscription that compounds; Goat Simulator 3 relies on one-shot IAP or ads.
- Bigger install base. Melon Sandbox has ~104.8M lifetime installs vs Goat Simulator 3's ~108K - 971.3× the funnel top.
- Better app store reviews. Melon Sandbox sits at 4.69★ vs 4.29★ - store algorithms reward higher-rated apps with more impressions.
→ Find more apps with this revenue gap · Full Melon Sandbox report
Side-by-side metrics
Bars scale to whichever app is bigger on that row. Green = winner.
Goat Simulator 3
vs
Melon Sandbox
Monthly revenue (est.)?
$16.8K
▶
$316.4K
Annual revenue (est.)
$201.9K
▶
$3.80M
Lifetime installs (est.)
108K
▶
104.8M
Monthly active users (est.)?
16K
▶
2.9M
App Store rating
4.29★
▶
4.69★
Total ratings
3K
▶
1.2M
US grossing rank
-
=
-
Cheapest monthly sub
No sub
▶
$11.29
IAP tiers detected
0 tiers
=
0 tiers
- Category
- Simulation
- Price
- USD12.99
- Released
- Dec 5, 2023
- Last updated
- Feb 20, 2026
- File size
- -
- Content rating
- Teen
- Version
- 1.1.6.3
- Languages
- -
- Category
- Simulation
- Price
- Free
- Released
- Dec 23, 2022
- Last updated
- Jun 24, 2026
- File size
- -
- Content rating
- Teen
- Version
- 36.1
- Languages
- -
Goat Simulator 3 trajectory
Melon Sandbox trajectory
FAQ
Which makes more money, Goat Simulator 3 or Melon Sandbox? v
Melon Sandbox earns about $316.4K per month, while Goat Simulator 3 earns about $16.8K. That is a 18.8× revenue gap (~$299.6K more per month for Melon Sandbox). Annual revenue: Goat Simulator 3 ≈ $201.9K/year, Melon Sandbox ≈ $3.80M/year. Estimates are derived from public Google Play signals - grossing rank, scraped IAP tiers, ratings and category benchmarks.
Which has more downloads, Goat Simulator 3 or Melon Sandbox? v
Melon Sandbox leads with about 104.8M estimated downloads vs 108K for Goat Simulator 3 - a 971.3× gap. Goat Simulator 3 reports 100,000+ installs on Google Play. Melon Sandbox reports 100,000,000+ installs on Google Play.
Are Goat Simulator 3 and Melon Sandbox in the same Google Play category and competing for the same money? v
Yes - both apps sit in the Simulation category, which means they compete directly for the same paying users and category-level wallet share. Direct competitors, head-to-head.
What in-app purchases and subscription pricing do Goat Simulator 3 and Melon Sandbox offer? v
Goat Simulator 3: no IAP detected on the public listing. Melon Sandbox: IAP range $0.49 - $259.99 per item. Goat Simulator 3 runs a "Paid app ($12.99)" monetization model; Melon Sandbox runs "Free game · IAP-driven (0 packs, ~$0.30/MAU)". Scraped tier prices and detected subscription pricing drive the bulk of the per-app revenue estimate above.
Which has better ratings, Goat Simulator 3 or Melon Sandbox? v
Melon Sandbox edges ahead with ★ 4.7 vs ★ 4.3 (gap of 0.4 stars). Rating volume: Goat Simulator 3 227 ratings, Melon Sandbox 50K ratings. Higher rating volume = stronger ASO signal even when star averages are close.
How accurate are these Goat Simulator 3 vs Melon Sandbox revenue estimates? v
Directional - typically within 2-3× of actual money earned for popular apps. The $16.8K for Goat Simulator 3 and $316.4K for Melon Sandbox are derived from Google Play grossing rank, scraped IAP tiers, ratings volume and category benchmarks (Simulation) - net of the 15-30% Apple/Google store cut. Real revenue depends on country mix, retention, refunds and ad fill rate, none of which Apple or Google publish.
How do I compare Goat Simulator 3 or Melon Sandbox to a different Google Play app? v
Use the search box at the bottom of this page or paste any two Google Play links into the homepage tool. We auto-generate a permanent comparison URL with revenue, downloads, IAP tiers, subscription pricing and grossing rank for both apps.