Review Insights · App Store
Magic Starㅤ
蕊 乐 · 579 ratings · ★ 3.8
3.8
★★★★★
579 ratings
🎯 Build a better version
Top complaints - extracted from 29 negative reviews
Recurring phrases mined from 1-2★ reviews. The bigger the percentage, the more users have the same problem. Fix the top 2-3 in your version and you have product-market fit on day one.
1
"game"
20 negative reviews mention this · 69% of all complaints
★★★★★ "False advertising. I downloaded the game and the first thing it made me do is drag numbers to match each other. Wth" - Bxiong05
2
"play"
7 negative reviews mention this · 24% of all complaints
★★★★★ "This game kicks me out for no reason. I was trying to play when all of a sudden it turned off. I don’t like when it does that. 👎🏿" - EvanCombo
3
"error"
6 negative reviews mention this · 21% of all complaints
★★★★★ "Cant log in. Bro wheres the developer contact information? I have an account and i got a new phone. When i tried to log back in, it says Data Error. Give me my account and contact information." - Xxfallz
4
"give"
5 negative reviews mention this · 17% of all complaints
★★★★★ "Nope!. Let’s start with the initial start up. It froze three times before I can even get the game to do it initial start-up update. Then as the game is downloading, it shows a picture nice of a someone playing a piano but yet there’s music playing…" - The_Real_Dacloud
5
"account"
5 negative reviews mention this · 17% of all complaints
★★★★★ "Cant log in. Bro wheres the developer contact information? I have an account and i got a new phone. When i tried to log back in, it says Data Error. Give me my account and contact information." - Xxfallz
6
"other"
4 negative reviews mention this · 14% of all complaints
★★★★★ "False advertising. I downloaded the game and the first thing it made me do is drag numbers to match each other. Wth" - Bxiong05
7
"phone"
4 negative reviews mention this · 14% of all complaints
★★★★★ "Embarrassment to Rhythm Games. Calling this a rhythm game when there is so much other nonsense is genuinely disrespectful. If you're going to advertise don't pretend like the main focus is the rhythm aspect. It's completely buggy (i have the newest phone and pretty good …" - abimaesi
8
"couldn"
4 negative reviews mention this · 14% of all complaints
★★★★★ "Embarrassment to Rhythm Games. Calling this a rhythm game when there is so much other nonsense is genuinely disrespectful. If you're going to advertise don't pretend like the main focus is the rhythm aspect. It's completely buggy (i have the newest phone and pretty good …" - abimaesi
9
"downloading"
4 negative reviews mention this · 14% of all complaints
★★★★★ "Nope!. Let’s start with the initial start up. It froze three times before I can even get the game to do it initial start-up update. Then as the game is downloading, it shows a picture nice of a someone playing a piano but yet there’s music playing…" - The_Real_Dacloud
10
"started"
4 negative reviews mention this · 14% of all complaints
★★★★★ "Nope!. Let’s start with the initial start up. It froze three times before I can even get the game to do it initial start-up update. Then as the game is downloading, it shows a picture nice of a someone playing a piano but yet there’s music playing…" - The_Real_Dacloud
11
"work"
4 negative reviews mention this · 14% of all complaints
★★★★★ "Try fixing your game. I give it a one star because at the first part of it I have plenty of speed and it goes out like in one second and also there’s a error I’ve tried turning off my phone restarting the game and it doesn’t work your gonna make me delete this g…" - kkxyfxjv xud dhd dh dhc
12
"reason"
3 negative reviews mention this · 10% of all complaints
★★★★★ "This game kicks me out for no reason. I was trying to play when all of a sudden it turned off. I don’t like when it does that. 👎🏿" - EvanCombo
📋 All 29 negative reviews
Every 1-2★ review we fetched. Use the copy button to grab them all for your own analysis (paste into ChatGPT/Claude with a prompt like "summarize core user problems, group by theme, ignore bugs, focus on missing features").
False advertising
I downloaded the game and the first thing it made me do is drag numbers to match each other. Wth
This game kicks me out for no reason
I was trying to play when all of a sudden it turned off. I don’t like when it does that. 👎🏿
Embarrassment to Rhythm Games
Calling this a rhythm game when there is so much other nonsense is genuinely disrespectful. If you're going to advertise don't pretend like the main focus is the rhythm aspect. It's completely buggy (i have the newest phone and pretty good wifi so i know its not me) and you can't even change the speed. You also can't customize anything else other than your avatar, which is a cute aspect but completely pointless when you have bad gameplay. I couldn't even figure out how to pick a song, but they were very thorough in showing me where all the stores were so I could spend money!! Stick to bandori and pjsekai if you actually want to play a rhythm game, play this if you want to drain your iphone storage and waste your time. In the middle of songs they stop for a second and dance, most times cutting off the best beats.
Nope!
Let’s start with the initial start up. It froze three times before I can even get the game to do it initial start-up update. Then as the game is downloading, it shows a picture nice of a someone playing a piano but yet there’s music playing in the background was this annoying R&B music which felt so out of place and not planned out. Then when the game finally started, I’m watching some creepy video of people who look like Barbies that breed Brats dolls and I’m like Nope! But for some reason, I decide to give the game a chance further, and it already started trying to sell me stuff annoying tutorial it forces me the do game modes before I can open mail.
Cant log in
Bro wheres the developer contact information? I have an account and i got a new phone. When i tried to log back in, it says Data Error. Give me my account and contact information.
Drama EVEEYWHERE
When I first started playing this game, I had a lot of fun! Made so many friends! But now I’m lvl 75 and have been playing for a year now maybe. I’m VIP 7. And I go by the name Pinky. This game has gone so far down into a hole that now all you when you go online is drama. Someone getting told to kill themself because they are “gay”. It’s so hard to go a day in this game without being bombshelled with negativity and stupidity.
I want my refund
This game is ripping me off I log back in after one year find out they took my items off from my account all of the expenses are gone. This game is a scam.
connection issues
i cannot connec to the game for whatever reason
Hey
Bad games for kids
hey.
yall should connect to the srilanka country. my only friend lives there 😭
Very long to start
I saw an add for this game but when I opened it the page just loaded and it took forever. I couldn’t even play the game! So please fix that.
Horrible
When i joined j had to add these things together like 2+2 which was easy but I never went into the real game I was stuck there for like 20 minutes! I think it's click bait never again!
Scam
So I downloaded this app a few days ago and I tried to login and
It said data error so I took a few minutes off the app and when I got back on the app it data error some I asked my dad to help he couldn’t and my router kept getting spam attempts so this I a
Scam
It said data error so I took a few minutes off the app and when I got back on the app it data error some I asked my dad to help he couldn’t and my router kept getting spam attempts so this I a
Scam
Please read
The marketing for this app is all stolen MMD videos ripped off of youtube, with no gameplay actually going on. Please don’t support this game whatsoever. Surprises me no one has caught onto this.
Can’t even start
So I’ve seen this game with ads and other things and it looks amazing. I tried to download it and it was successful. The problem started when I tried to make an account it said that there was an error I went back and tried the guest login and still said error. I deleted the app then reinstalled it downloading was quick but same problem occurred still said error on both making an account and the guest login. This game looks good but you can’t even login plz fix it
Try fixing your game
I give it a one star because at the first part of it I have plenty of speed and it goes out like in one second and also there’s a error I’ve tried turning off my phone restarting the game and it doesn’t work your gonna make me delete this game so work on it it’s making me angry
sussy baka
WAAAAAAAAAAAAaAa
Beware of Shady Marketing
I and other YouTube creators have noticed ads for this game in multiple sites where they used our videos without consent. They are profiting off of our content that takes months to make for their own personal gain and they never give any sort of credit to the people that actually put in the hard work to make them. Please don’t support this game!
Issue starting the app
So I just got the game because it looked like fun, the first time I loaded it up it did the whole download resources song and dance, and I was fine with waiting for it but I had to look something up and exited the app, when I entered the app once again so it could finish downloading it gave me a pop up saying “self update error” and that it couldn’t receive the server version. I’ve tried restarting the app, deleting it off my phone and reinstalling it I’ve tried using different internet connections and my hotspot but nothing has worked. I hope this can be fixed because I want to play it
i joined a guild on accident I WANNA LEAVEERR
pls
Why can I not get in when I am new.
Hello. I am Here to tell I tried downloading The game today and When I barely Got in it Said About Account login. I tried Registering But It did not work. I tried Everything and Nothing seems to happen at all. Pls Do something about this or give Me some Advice on What to do.
This is not Fair or Something
This is not Fair or Something
Annoying
It takes up so much memory it’s good and everything but it’s just that that is annoying
I can’t play with cellular data?!
So recently today, I can’t seem to play because my internet needs to be payed for or turned back on.. so I just thought “oh I have cellular data.. I can just get in magic star..” so I went on and it says I can’t be on without internet connection.. so please make it to where I can play with cellular data.. because then my girlfriend will think I deleted the game if my internet isn’t payed and I’m 13 years old.. I have no control of paying for the internet..-
Omg pls help idk what is going on
I just opened the app and befire everyone started a pop up showed on my screen. It said <color=#f00>SELFUP-DATE_ERROR_TITLE_2</color>
Do you know how to fix this? 😭
Do you know how to fix this? 😭
Ranked
When it comes to ranked or any dance your doing it accumulates the pairings too slow so when you think you won you lost sometimes because then it gives everyone else 5k+ points at the end then your left in 3rd or last when if you were in the middle of the game you would’ve tried to do better to win
Why won’t it load?
The game looks really fun and I’d love to play it, however, when I opened it and created my account it stopped loading even after I got the update I let the game load for over an hour and I’m still not able to play. Please tell me there’s a way to fix this.
It would be 5 stars but,
The amount of children bullying children is absolutely disgusting. There needs to be a community manager to handle toxic behaviors because your reporting system is terrible.
My review
Well, the tutorial is too much. I cant stand how long it is, please get rid of it and just tell the basics. It’s so annoying on how the “monitor” bot has to control everything you do in the beginning of the game.
How do I play the game in the beginning when I download it
Hey, I’m just wondering how do I play the actual game? I’m really confused and does the game only work on Android (I’m not dumb I’m just asking).
Sentiment summary
69%
Positive (4-5★)
8%
Neutral (3★)
23%
Negative (1-2★)